Heading the Ball in Soccer: A Silent Threat to Cognitive Health

Image of a teen female holding a soccer ball in one arm and holding her head with the other hand, looking like her head hurts from playing soccer.
$

Written By: Dr. Starr, MD, FAACAP

Dr. Starr is a medical doctor, psychiatrist and computational neuroscientist who has been active in Brain-Computer Interface and Neurofeedback since 1990.

To learn more about neurofeedback, please read the article; What Is Neurofeedback. If you are interested in home neurofeedback please read the article; Neurofeedback At Home.

Heading the Ball in Soccer

Soccer is often celebrated for its fast pace, thrilling goals, and the skillful play of athletes. However, recent research has unearthed a concerning aspect of the beautiful game: the cognitive impairment associated with heading the ball. This article delves into the findings of various studies, expert opinions, prevention strategies, and case studies to understand the impact of heading on brain health.

Key Findings on Heading and Cognitive Impairment

Multiple studies have demonstrated a clear correlation between heading the ball in soccer and cognitive impairment. The effects are notably significant in younger players, indicating that the developing brain may be especially vulnerable.

  1. Memory and Attention: Research indicates a decline in verbal and visual memory and a reduction in attention span among players who frequently head the ball.
  2. Youth Vulnerability: The impact is particularly pronounced in younger players, suggesting their developing brains are more susceptible to damage.
  3. Cumulative Effect: The potential for cumulative damage over time is significant, with more frequent heading associated with greater cognitive decline.

Studies like those conducted by the University of Stirling and published in journals such as JAMA provide a data-driven foundation for these conclusions.

Expert Opinions on Heading in Soccer

Insights from experts in sports medicine and neurology further highlight the risks associated with heading the ball:

  • Dr. Lisa Feldman Barrett, Professor of Psychology at Northeastern University, states, “The repeated impacts on the head from heading a soccer ball can lead to brain damage similar to what we see in professional boxers and football players. We need to be more cautious, especially with younger players.”
  • Dr. Michael Lipton, Professor of Radiology and Psychiatry at Albert Einstein College of Medicine, comments, “Our research shows that heading the ball is related to cognitive deficits, particularly for memory and attention. It’s important to consider the risks and benefits, especially in youth soccer where the brain is still developing.”
  • Dr. John O’Kane, Director of Research at the University of Glasgow’s Institute of Neuroscience and Psychology, emphasizes, “The cumulative effects of repetitive heading are concerning, especially given the growing evidence of the long-term consequences of head injuries in sport. We need to continue studying the impact of heading in soccer and develop strategies to protect players.”

Prevention Strategies

To minimize the risks associated with heading in soccer, several strategies and recommendations have been suggested by experts:

  1. Proper Heading Technique: Encourage teaching and practicing proper heading techniques to reduce the impact on the head.
  2. Protective Headgear: Promote the use of protective headgear during training and matches, particularly for young players.
  3. Age-Specific Guidelines: Implement guidelines that limit the amount of heading in practice and games for youth players.
  4. Frequent Breaks: Emphasize frequent breaks during training sessions to reduce the cumulative effect of heading.
  5. Education: Educate coaches, parents, and players on the signs and symptoms of concussions and the importance of reporting head injuries.
  6. Research and Development: Support ongoing research into developing safer soccer balls that minimize the impact on players.

Case studies provide tangible examples of the effects of heading on cognitive health:

  1. University of Stirling Study (2017): Examined 123 amateur soccer players, aged 18-55, finding that those who headed the ball most frequently showed poorer cognitive performance, particularly in memory and attention, compared to infrequent headers.
  1. Female Professional Player: A 23-year-old professional female soccer player reported memory lapses and difficulty concentrating after regular heading practice. MRI scans revealed structural changes in her brain consistent with mild traumatic brain injury.
  2. JAMA Study (2018): Analysis of brain tissue from deceased soccer players, including one with over 20 years of heading practice, showed evidence of chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), prompting further investigation into the long-term neurological effects of heading.

How Can Myneurva Help

Myneurva’s ANNA can help to predict such neurological issues based on your QEEG results, in seconds!

Conclusion

The evidence linking heading the ball in soccer to cognitive impairment is compelling. From memory lapses to attention deficits, the risks are particularly acute for younger players and those who head the ball frequently.

Given the potential for long-term neurological damage, it’s imperative to adopt prevention strategies, educate stakeholders, and continue research into safer practices and technologies. As Dr. Lisa Feldman Barrett aptly points out, “We need to be more cautious, especially with younger players.”

By understanding and addressing these risks, we can help ensure that the beautiful game remains safe for all who play it.

For further reading on this topic, here are some external resources:

Stay informed, stay safe, and let’s make soccer a game everyone can enjoy without compromising health.

Myneurva Is A Global Leader In Neurofeedback and QEEG Analysis

Myneurva is a global leader in computational QEEG analysis. Dr. Starr holds the US patent for a System and method for analyzing electroencephalogram signals.

From The Neurofeedback Blog...

Neurofeedback 101: Everything You Need to Know

Neurofeedback 101: Everything You Need to Know Before Starting Neurofeedback At Home Neurofeedback therapy is an intriguing and innovative approach to understanding and influencing brain activity. It's a non-invasive method that has garnered attention from mental...

Neurofeedback For Therapists – A Superior Toolbox

Revolutionizing Therapy with Neurofeedback For TherapistsWhat is Neurofeedback?Fundamental Principles and Techniques of Neurofeedback TrainingKey Benefits of Neurofeedback for TherapistsCase Studies: Successful Neurofeedback Applications in TherapyPractical Steps for...

The Neurofeedback Session: What to Expect

The Neurofeedback Session: What to Expect Neurofeedback is rapidly gaining recognition as an effective method for optimizing mental performance and alleviating symptoms linked to various conditions such as depression, TBI, ADHD and anxiety. For athletes, it represents...

What Are EEG-Neuroendophenotypes?

What is a Phenotype? Let’s look at the etymology, or the origin of words, to understand “What is a Phenotype.” The etymology of pheno comes from the Greek meaning to show. In biology, a phenotype is a trait expressed by an organism due to the DNA it has inherited from...

Debunking Myths About Neurofeedback Therapy

Addressing Misconceptions: Debunking Myths About Neurofeedback Therapy Neurofeedback therapy, a non-invasive technique aimed at teaching the brain to function more efficiently, has steadily gained recognition among health enthusiasts, mental health advocates, and...

Harnessing Brain Power: Neurofeedback for Emotional Trauma

Neurofeedback for Emotional Trauma - Introduction Emotional trauma, whether from childhood abuse, domestic violence, military combat, or life-altering accidents, leaves profound imprints on individuals' lives. Traditional therapeutic approaches have made significant...

The History Of Neurofeedback

History of Neurofeedback: From Discovery to Modern Applications Neurofeedback has emerged as a groundbreaking modality for improving brain function and treating various psychological and neurological conditions. Its journey from early scientific discoveries to modern...

Neurofeedback For Tinnitus

Introduction to Neurofeedback For Tinnitus Tinnitus, often described as a persistent ringing, buzzing, or hissing sound in the ears, affects millions of individuals worldwide. This condition can range from a mild annoyance to a debilitating issue that significantly...

Meet Your Neurofeedback Expert

Featured Neurofeedback Articles

Call Us

Hours

M-F: 7am - 5pm EST
S-S: Closed